If you are shopping for a synthetic slate, shake or tile roof in Los Angeles, two names come up first: DaVinci Roofscapes and Brava Roof Tile. Both make premium composite roofing, and both look excellent on the right home. They are not identical, though. Here is a clear comparison so you can narrow the choice before we visit your property.
The Short Version
- DaVinci Roofscapes focuses on composite slate and shake, with a refined, architectural look.
- Brava Roof Tile offers composite slate, cedar shake and Spanish barrel tile, which makes it a strong choice for Mediterranean and Spanish-style homes.
Both are lightweight compared with natural stone and clay, resist cracking, rot and curling, and are widely sold with Class A fire ratings and Class 4 impact ratings. Always check the exact rating of the specific product and assembly you choose.
Profiles and Styles
DaVinci Roofscapes
We install the DaVinci slate and shake lines. Options include DaVinci composite slate (multi-width, single-width and select) and DaVinci composite shake (multi-width, single-width and select). These are a natural fit for traditional, colonial, French country and high-end custom homes.
Brava Roof Tile
Brava gives you three families: slate, cedar shake and Spanish barrel tile. If your home has a Spanish or Mediterranean style and you want the clay barrel look without the clay weight, Brava is often the better match.
How to Choose Between Them
- Start with your home’s architecture. A Spanish-style home usually points to Brava Spanish tile. A traditional or estate-style home often points to composite slate from either maker.
- Look at the color in real light. Samples look different in morning sun, shade and next to your trim and stucco. Compare in person on your own roof.
- Check neighborhood and HOA rules. Some communities have approved materials and color lists. Confirm before you order.
- Review the installation and warranty requirements. Each manufacturer has its own installation specifications, and warranty coverage can depend on following them and using approved components. Ask who provides which warranty and what it covers.
- Consider availability. Popular profiles and colors can have lead times.
What Is the Same, Whichever You Pick
The brand is only part of the roof. What protects your home is the whole system: underlayment, flashing, ventilation, fastening and the metal details at valleys, edges, chimneys and penetrations. As a licensed C-39 roofing and C-43 sheet metal contractor, Eclipse Remodeling & Roofing Inc. fabricates custom copper and aluminum flashings in-house for each roof. A great tile installed with weak details will still leak, and a well-detailed roof will outlast a careless one in either brand.
Cost and What Affects It
Composite roofing is a premium material, and neither brand is the budget choice. Pricing depends on the profile, roof size and pitch, complexity, tear-off and deck repair, underlayment, and the metal work required. We do not quote a price per square foot without seeing the roof, because it would be a guess. An on-site inspection gives you a real number.
So Which One Should You Choose?
There is no single winner. Choose DaVinci if you want a refined slate or shake look for a traditional or custom home. Choose Brava if you want the widest style range, especially Spanish barrel tile. The best way to decide is to see both on a real roof. We can show you completed projects, bring samples and walk you through the options. Serving Pacific Palisades, Bel-Air, Beverly Hills and the greater Los Angeles area, call (818) 497-3449 or schedule a roof consultation. You can also read our composite roof tile overview.
Common Questions
Are DaVinci and Brava roofs fire rated?
Both makers offer products commonly sold with a Class A rating, the highest roof fire classification. The rating depends on the specific product and the complete roof assembly, so ask for the listing that applies to your roof.
Will the color fade?
Both brands use UV-stable color technology designed to resist fading. No outdoor material stays exactly the same forever, so ask each manufacturer what its warranty says about color change.
Can composite tile be installed over an existing roof?
In most cases we remove the old roofing so we can inspect and, if needed, repair the deck and install new underlayment and flashing. Your inspection will confirm what your roof needs.
How long does installation take?
It depends on roof size, complexity and weather. After the inspection we give you a realistic schedule for your project.
Important Note
This comparison is general information only. Product lines, ratings, warranties, codes and availability change and vary by property. Please verify the current specifications with the manufacturer, your local building department and your contractor before making a final decision.